Panaji: A member of the Command Area Development Authority (CADA) for the Tillari irrigation project has said that state govt made an illegal decision to denotify 3.3 lakh sqm of irrigation land at Dhargalim for a casino firm, and it will not withstand scrutiny in court.
The CADA member and Aldona MLA Carlos Alvares Ferreira said that six months ago, the CADA notified these as command areas. “I am surprised and shocked to see a news report in TOI that about 3.3 lakh square metres of land at Dhargal, Pernem, is sought to be gifted to a casino company called Delta Corp Ltd to set up their gaming zone over there by converting CADA land,” Ferreira said. “The land is for an irrigation project, by govt, which has blessed this (the denotification) in a totally fraudulent and illegal manner.”
The Command Area Development Act was enacted with the intention to protect lands of farmers and provide irrigation facilities. That is how a lot of tracts were given the facility of irrigation and were classified as CADA land for the purpose of providing them water to sustain agriculture.
“On the one hand, govt has brought out a policy for agriculture which says that CADA land should not be converted,” Ferreira said. “On the other hand, govt is with one stroke of the pen gifting away CADA land by purportedly denotifying it for the purposes of a casino.”
He added, “First and foremost, I want to say that notified CADA land is pursuant to a scheme. There is a procedure under the Act where a scheme is prepared, land is identified, and then the scheme is notified for objections.”
After objections are received, he said, the CADA board approves the scheme with or without modifications.
“I am a member of the CADA board, and at the last CADA meeting at which I was present, I ensured that we took up this notification approval, and I made sure that the board approved the entire scheme,” Ferreira said. “Therefore, pursuant to the board resolution, the area was notified in terms of the Act.”
Ferreira, a senior advocate, said, “Now, what I have learnt is this company applies to the Investment Promotion Board (IPB), and the IPB makes a proposal to govt, and the cabinet takes a decision to denotify the land.”
He added, “The first thing I want to point out is that when there is an Act, whether passed by Parliament or a state assembly, when there is an enactment, there is a law. When there is a law, you have to do it in accordance with that law.”
The law required the preparation of a scheme, a notification for objections, and then consideration by the board, he said, adding that once the board considers it, it gets notified as an approved scheme.
“The cabinet has no power to override the CADA board constituted under a statute. The cabinet, however supreme it may be under its executive prerogative, cannot override statutory powers given to an authority under an Act,” a senior advocate said. “Therefore, the decision of the cabinet, being taken in total ignorance or bypassing of the CADA board, is totally illegal and will not stand the test when scrutinised by a court of law.”
Ferreira said, “I think this is wrong. This is proof that govt wants to sell lands, actually gift away lands, to casinos and to all these people who want to develop in real estate and who are trying to finish Goa.”
He added, “BJP, which once stood against casinos and said it will remove them, is encouraging casinos.”
Referring to the cabinet decision to waive Rs 5 crore for the company, a senior advocate said, “I call upon govt and BJP to explain who has pocketed this money. I am sure somebody took this money when you are giving this waiver.”
Further, he said, “Definitely, if not all, 50% or more profit might have gone into somebody’s pocket. This is a corrupt act and an illegal act.”
The CADA member and Aldona MLA Carlos Alvares Ferreira said that six months ago, the CADA notified these as command areas. “I am surprised and shocked to see a news report in TOI that about 3.3 lakh square metres of land at Dhargal, Pernem, is sought to be gifted to a casino company called Delta Corp Ltd to set up their gaming zone over there by converting CADA land,” Ferreira said. “The land is for an irrigation project, by govt, which has blessed this (the denotification) in a totally fraudulent and illegal manner.”
The Command Area Development Act was enacted with the intention to protect lands of farmers and provide irrigation facilities. That is how a lot of tracts were given the facility of irrigation and were classified as CADA land for the purpose of providing them water to sustain agriculture.
“On the one hand, govt has brought out a policy for agriculture which says that CADA land should not be converted,” Ferreira said. “On the other hand, govt is with one stroke of the pen gifting away CADA land by purportedly denotifying it for the purposes of a casino.”
He added, “First and foremost, I want to say that notified CADA land is pursuant to a scheme. There is a procedure under the Act where a scheme is prepared, land is identified, and then the scheme is notified for objections.”
After objections are received, he said, the CADA board approves the scheme with or without modifications.
“I am a member of the CADA board, and at the last CADA meeting at which I was present, I ensured that we took up this notification approval, and I made sure that the board approved the entire scheme,” Ferreira said. “Therefore, pursuant to the board resolution, the area was notified in terms of the Act.”
Ferreira, a senior advocate, said, “Now, what I have learnt is this company applies to the Investment Promotion Board (IPB), and the IPB makes a proposal to govt, and the cabinet takes a decision to denotify the land.”
He added, “The first thing I want to point out is that when there is an Act, whether passed by Parliament or a state assembly, when there is an enactment, there is a law. When there is a law, you have to do it in accordance with that law.”
The law required the preparation of a scheme, a notification for objections, and then consideration by the board, he said, adding that once the board considers it, it gets notified as an approved scheme.
“The cabinet has no power to override the CADA board constituted under a statute. The cabinet, however supreme it may be under its executive prerogative, cannot override statutory powers given to an authority under an Act,” a senior advocate said. “Therefore, the decision of the cabinet, being taken in total ignorance or bypassing of the CADA board, is totally illegal and will not stand the test when scrutinised by a court of law.”
Ferreira said, “I think this is wrong. This is proof that govt wants to sell lands, actually gift away lands, to casinos and to all these people who want to develop in real estate and who are trying to finish Goa.”
He added, “BJP, which once stood against casinos and said it will remove them, is encouraging casinos.”
Referring to the cabinet decision to waive Rs 5 crore for the company, a senior advocate said, “I call upon govt and BJP to explain who has pocketed this money. I am sure somebody took this money when you are giving this waiver.”
Further, he said, “Definitely, if not all, 50% or more profit might have gone into somebody’s pocket. This is a corrupt act and an illegal act.”
You may also like
Turkey learns the cost of siding with Pakistan: Indian tourists cancel in droves
Mystery of barbaric murder that haunts every woman as wrongly jailed Peter Sullivan to be freed
Andrey Santos Chelsea transfer truth as shock £45m Arsenal twist explained
Lowest retail inflation since 2019 provides further leeway to cut rates: Experts
Labour civil war erupts as Keir Starmer sparks fury with migration plans
