Donovan Mitchell's injury status for Cleveland Cavaliers vs Indiana Pacers Game 5 (May 13, 2025)

The Cleveland Cavaliers are fighting to stay alive in the playoffs as they host the Indiana Pacers in a do-or-die Game 5. The biggest question looming over the game is whether star guard Donovan Mitchell will play after suffering an ankle injury in Game 4.

Will Donovan Mitchell play tonight against the Indiana Pacers in Game 5? (May 13, 2025)

Donovan Mitchell’s availability remains up in the air after he exited Game 4 early due to a flare-up of his ankle injury. Despite attempting to play through it, he was ruled out for the second half, leaving the Cleveland Cavaliers without their leading scorer in a pivotal loss.

Key updates on Mitchell’s status:

- An MRI confirmed the ankle injury is a recurring issue.

- NBA insider Shams Charania reported Mitchell will be a game-time decision.

- The Cavaliers have not provided a definitive update, leaving his status uncertain until tipoff.

How Donovan Mitchell’s absence would impact the Cleveland Cavaliers

Donovan Mitchell officially listed as questionable for Game 5. No one on the Pacers' injury report other than Isaiah Jackson.

— Dustin Dopirak (@DustinDopirak) May 12, 2025

If Mitchell can’t suit up, Cleveland faces a steep challenge. He has been the team’s primary offensive weapon, especially with other key players already sidelined.

Here’s how the Cavaliers’ performance stacks up with and without Mitchell in this series:

Scenario

Points per game

Series record



Without Mitchell, the Cavaliers lack a reliable closer, and their offense becomes more predictable. The Pacers, already leading the series 3-1, would have a clear path to closing it out.

Can Donovan Mitchell still swing the series if he plays?

Even at less than 100%, Donovan Mitchell has shown he can take over games. His ability to create shots and draw defensive attention opens up opportunities for teammates. If he plays, the Cleveland Cavaliers have a fighting chance to extend the series.

Factors working in Mitchell’s favor:

- Playoff experience in high-pressure games.

- A history of playing through injuries.

- The urgency of an elimination game.

However, if he’s limited, the Pacers’ defense—led by pesky perimeter defenders—could exploit his lack of mobility.

What to expect from Cleveland Cavaliers vs Indiana Pacers Game 5 (May 13, 2025)

Game 5 tips off tonight at Rocket Mortgage FieldHouse, and all eyes will be on Mitchell’s status. If he plays, the Cleveland Cavaliers could regain momentum. If not, their season may be on the brink.

For now, fans will have to wait until game time for the final word on whether Cleveland’s star will take the floor in this must-win showdown.